Read the prior post about reviewing for some requirements to have your review accepted. Ill be making sure your reviews are fair and unbias and if they get accepted and there becomes a consensus that your review was poor then it will be removed.
Cheers :)
ID:39196
 Feb 14 2008, 7:52 pm
|
|
|
Feb 14 2008, 7:53 pm
|
|
Ryokashi
 |
I was going to say when I saw that topic title, "Oh shit, this won't end well". But yeah, if it's just submitting for discussion, I guess that's fine.
|
unbiased?, Cool now i can write about how much i hate GOA >:-)
| |
Tubutas wrote:
unbiased?, Cool now i can write about how much i hate GOA >:-) Whoo! Math is power! | |
Ryokashi wrote:
Tubutas wrote: Keeping in mind the review itself has to be unbias to, You cant diss on nbotls for being gay and "for fags" or anything like that. Nor can you submit a review of all the stuff you dont like about my game just to see if ill accept it (i wont). Conversely, If you make a review and theres fair critisism (and i dont need to abuse my position i would prefer a fair review) and you also fairly offset it with redeeming qualities, of course ill accept it. | |
Masterdan wrote:
Ryokashi wrote: So we can't talk about the bad things about your game? I thought you said it wasn't bias. =) | |
Masterdan wrote:
Ryokashi wrote: =p that was a joke. | |
You should make some sort of rubric that people can reference. They wouldn't necessarily have to follow it but if they don't know what to do then they can reference it. Maybe make a notepad with some pre-made html or something, and have them fill in the blanks.
| |
lol, i said you cant make a review ONLY about the bad things in my game. Reviews are complete summaries of a game, you cant just make a rant post about a game and call it a review.
| |
IcewarriorX wrote:
You should make some sort of rubric that people can reference. They wouldn't necessarily have to follow it but if they don't know what to do then they can reference it. Maybe make a notepad with some pre-made html or something, and have them fill in the blanks. I definitely will do that but right now i have an assignment due tomorrow as well as an accounting test so im kind of sketchy! | |
IcewarriorX wrote:
On a sidenote..Is there a reason my DMO review doesn't show up on their hud? :/ The review is being judged, probably. | |
IcewarriorX wrote:
Alright. Nah it wasnt that, theres actually a field at the bottom of a for submission post that allows you to search for and select the game your reviewing. I did it for you. | |
Oh ok. Thanks, it looked like it was pre-selected when filling out the form so I didn't bother with it.
| |
oh, so i can rant about everything i hate about your game and the things that are bordlinely tolerable and we can call that a review?
| |
Tubutas wrote:
oh, so i can rant about everything i hate about your game and the things that are bordlinely tolerable and we can call that a review? I don't think it works like that...If it does then I'm going to rant about how "borderlinely" is a made up word. *Grammar Police won* | |
IcewarriorX wrote:
Tubutas wrote: borderline torerable okay... | |
theres no borderline tolerable, either a review is an accurate objective depiction of a game or it isnt. There is no way to avoid the masterdan-filter and pass a rant off as a review. It will not happen.
| |
He gives overly sugary reviews. I agree and we need to get some criteria posted. I recommend somebody do that :)
| |
Well i came out of nowhere and completely changed the entire site without even talking to SSGX, i thought changing his slogan would be kind of a diss.
| |
Only about 3 or 4 of them would be able to come up with an "original" one though. :) but go ahead and try for it!
| |