ID:3763
 

Like most people, you probably have a number of devices that run on battery power. Could be clocks, cameras, portable stereos, flashlights, remote controls, ... Like most people, you probably buy your Duracell or Energizer batteries at the store and throw them away when they're spent, right?

That's exactly what the battery companies want you to do: keep buying more and more batteries. More profit for them.

But there is an alternative. Many of your electronic devices may already have customized versions of this built in - many digital cameras, laptops, and portable music players have this: rechargeable batteries.

Rechargeables are not just for custom applications. They make rechargeables in nearly all standard battery sizes: AA, AAA, 9-volt, C, D. They typically last longer than standard alkaline batteries (the throw-away kind) and can be recharged about 500-1000 times. Let's do some math:

  • A pack of 4 AA batteries costs $2.74 at Wal-Mart. Let's say you have a portable CD player that goes through 2 AAs every 3 days. Thus you buy 5 packs every month:

    $13.70/month or $164.40/year

  • A charger that charges 4 AA or AAA rechargeable batteries in 1 hour will cost you anywhere from $20-$30. We'll assume worst case: $30.00.

  • A 4-pack of rechargeable AA batteries will run you about $10.00. Those batteries will recharge about 500-1000 times, so we'll assume the worst case, or 500 recharge cycles.

Let's look at your total spent, month by month:

Month Disposable Rechargeable
1 $13.70 $40.00
2 $27.40 $40.00
3 $41.10 $40.00
4 $54.80 $40.00
5 $68.50 $40.00
6 $82.20 $40.00
7 $95.90 $40.00
8 $109.60 $40.00
9 $123.30 $40.00
10 $137.00 $40.00
11 $150.70 $40.00
12 $164.40 $40.00
. . .
80 $1,096.00 $40.00

After 80 months, you'll have recharged the batteries 480 times, or about half of their maximum recharge cycles. If you were unlucky, they may be near their end of life, in which case you saved "only" about $1,000. For one application!

Update:DeathAwaitsU correctly points out that you also have to consider the cost of recharging the batteries. The most expensive electricity in my market costs about $0.22 per kilowatt-hour. Most of it's much less, but this rate kicks in when you've gone over your baseline energy usage for the month. AA batteries put out 1.2 volts of electricity. And a typical rechargeable AA stores about 2500 milliamp-hours, or mAh, of electrical charge (see below).

Now, for a physics lesson.

  • Electricity from the power company is measured in kilowatt-hours (kWh), which is a unit of energy.
  • A watt is a unit of power, which is energy per unit time. 1 watt = 1 joule per second, or 1 W = 1 J/s
  • A coulomb (C) is a measure of electrical charge.
  • An ampere (A) is a measure of electrical current flowing through something, or number of coulombs per second. 1 A = 1 C/s
  • A volt is a measure of electrical potential, or energy per unit charge. 1 V = 1 J/C

Time to put it all together:

($0.22 / kWh)   *   (1 kW / 1000 W) = $0.00022 / Wh
($0.00022 / Wh)   *   (1 h / 3600 s) = $0.00000006111 / Ws
1 Ws = 1 (J/s)s = 1 J
Energy cost = $0.00000006111 per Joule

Energy stored in 4 charged AA batteries:
4 * 2500 mAh * 1.2 V = 10000 mAh * 1.2 V = 10 Ah * 1.2 V
10 Ah * (3600 s / h) * 1.2 J/C = 36000 As * 1.2 J/C
36000 As * 1.2 J/C = 36000 C * 1.2 J/C = 43,200 Joules

Multiplying by the energy cost per Joule, we get:
43,200 J * $0.00000006111 / J = $0.0026 to charge 4 batteries - less than a third of a cent.

After 480 charge cycles, we pay about a dollar for the electricity to charge the batteries.

Use rechargeables for everything that needs batteries, and you can save quite a bit more. Plus you help save the environment by throwing away far fewer spent batteries! The battery companies don't want you to know this - that's why they quietly make rechargeables but never advertise them.

Personally, I have a few sets of AAAs and several sets of AAs on hand. I use them in everything from my digital camera (which got me started on rechargeables 5 years ago) to remote controls, clocks, and more.

You can buy rechargeables at most stores that sell disposable batteries, and they also sell chargers too. However those chargers tend to be lower quality and will often cut short the number of usable charge cycles you get out of your batteries. I've had good luck with Maha chargers, which can be had at Thomas Distributing (I personally recommend them).

For batteries, look at the total charge rating, which is normally expressed in mAh - milliamp-hours. 2500 mAh is a pretty good capacity for AA rechargeables these days, and it means one battery can output an electrical current of 1 milliamp for 2500 hours. Or 2500 milliamps for 1 hour.

When you do the math, this is the biggest no-brainer in the history of mankind!

Good call. Rechargeable batteries are an easy cost saver. So are fluorescent bulbs. With the added benefit that they help the environment while saving you money. How's this? The decreased packaging and waste coupled with the reduction of energy usage for the bulbs. Neato!
You're forgetting the cost to recharge them. Recharging isn't exactly free you know, you have to pay the electricity bill. Not to mention rechargeable batteries get decharged quite easily. And finally, many many devices (including my TV remote) say that using a rechargeable battery would over charge the system and that it is strongly unrecommended. I do agree though that normal batteries have no place in devices such as a digital camera.
Why did you go and figure all this out?
Thanks for reminding me, DeathAwaitsU. I was originally planning to add the recharge cost in my analysis but forgot. If you check the updated post, you'll see that the cost is negligible.

You make other good points as well. Rechargeable batteries typically won't sit on the shelf and retain their charge as long as disposables, but they are getting better (the batteries in my remote lasted about 8 months before needing a recharge). And in most cases, that's a silly reason not to use them - just stick them in the charger for an hour or two and they're good as new!

I've seen that some devices aren't recommended for use with rechargeables, and I'm not sure why that is (the paranoid conspiracy theorist chimes in and says that they are in collusion with battery companies to make sure you buy disposables!) ;p. Rechargeables typically provide a more constant output of electricity over each cycle, rather than gradually dwindling down as disposables do. Seems to me that makes them better in all cases. Maybe I'll try to research it.

As for why figuring this out, don't you like saving lots of money? :)
It isnt really that hard to figure out (No offence Mike. :P)
You're still off, Mike! Your calculations assume that the charger is perfectly electrically efficient. However, battery chargers heat up over time. This proves that they aren't completely efficient - I'll bet you spend more money on recharging than you think . . . perhaps as much as $1.50!
I own a wireless optical mouse that simply INHALES batteries... I also own a battery charger, with 4 perfectly good rechargeable AA's...

Thanks for giving me the motivational boost to get the thing out of the box it was packed in and start using them again!
I used to use reghargables but nothing I own really uses batteries anymore (anything that does has built in re-chargables).
The main problem I found with them is they're annoying. I was going through about 2xAA a day which meant I had to get home from school, make sure they were discharged completely, put them on the charger and remember to pick them up the next morning before I left.
If I forgot to put them on or got home late I was screwed the next day. I had four AAs but using both pairs in tandem was still annoying.

Also it's not just a case of them hitting 500 charges and dying. They gradually die over those 500-1000 uses.

I'm not saying those are great reasons to use disposables, like I said I used rechargables despite hating them so much.
Although there was a phase where I'd just buy a bulk pack of 40 for around $20-$25AU. They were very high quality (there are a bunch of remotes around my house with four year old batteries in them).
However, rechargeable batteries do die. Eventually you will have to replace them. That’s an extra $10.00 every so often.
Depending on the brand, the batteries can die after one month, or after twenty-four.
I own a wireless optical mouse that simply INHALES batteries...

Yeah. Wireless is awesome isn't it? >_>

Why would you use a wireless mouse? There are way too many online games (like...all of them) where it would absolutely make you angry if your mouse or keyboard cut out...

Instead you can use keyboards and stuff with wires and adaptors (and never use portable CD players because they're no fun)

The new Gameboys all use adapters don't they? (SP, DS, and the micro or whatever) I think the reason SP's had cost so much more than GBA is because they had the light :P If Nintendo was thinking they'd have made it more pricy because the batteries just kill you financially if you play it enough (Although I can't play Gameboys often because the only reason I would is if I were traveling, and I get pounding headaches when I read or play Gameboy in the car x_x so there goes that theory. I just use Game Boy Player on my GCN at home, so I don't need my SP much unless I'm playing when I'm supposed to be asleep or something :P)