EDIT 1:

EDIT 2:

Theres me and another Player in, we are not Private our Byond Pager are open and running correctly.
Example 2:
EDIT 1: 2 ingame, 1 on website.

EDIT 2: 3 ingame, 2 on website.

Don't have a screenshot yet, but sometimes it will show 0 Players on the website while ingame there is 3+ and Byond website will report it as 0 Players.
Example 3:
EDIT 1:

When restarting a server this is what happens, even though the 2nd one doesn't exist anymore it still keeps it on the website somehow until that Player quits the game thats already been closed. I've restarted server 8 hours ago. It even reports as 2 players even though theres only 1 actual server running and only me in it.
I'm sure more have seen this issue so please replay, and showcase the problem in action.