Is Accuracy Important?

ID:1449530
 
Dec 21 2013, 3:20 am

Poll: Should fangames make characters just like the one in shows/movies?

Yes 28% (6)
No 38% (8)
Doesn't Matter 33% (7)

Login to vote.

In games such as:

Spider-Man
Naruto
DMC

Is the accuracy really important. If you were to play any of these games and the character didn't resemble their true image would you stop playing or would you be like "Gameplay over graphics".
Dec 21 2013, 10:42 am
I voted "Doesn't matter" because it depends on the game. It either copies the story or is original story just with similar theme (superpowers/jutsus/monsters in balls/other objects).
Dec 21 2013, 10:59 am
I voted no largely because fangames that remain true to the animes/manga are destined to not really be games.

.Hack//Sign and SAO are kind of exceptions to that rule.
Dec 21 2013, 11:12 am
I don't think people play these games for accuracy, rather IP.
Dec 26 2013, 10:23 am
I think the better games tend to be those that are of the same theme without being exact copies. It also gives you freedom to mold the world in a way that fits the type of game that you're making. Some games justify this by stating that the game is set in the future/past. You could really go either way, but the game would probably be better if you add your own ideas into the mix