Icon off icons, you be the judge

Page: 1 2
ID:192473
 
Jun 18 2002, 10:29 am
Im hoping fuzzy posts below, we decided not to do it in 32 x 32 because fuz' doesnt feel secure enough to use those to judge a competition, so we did it in pixels around 60 x 120. Here is mine, the theme was fighter of any race and type *Very Open*.

NeoHaxor

This is what I see when I describe a char to fit my BYOND key.
NeoHaXor the Ghetto Alien.

The following are the categories to judge on *Neither me or him can judge, nor can we bash on anyone *In respect to the forum moderator*.

Originality: (1-10)
*How original the icon is*
Dedication: (1-10)
*Rate on how much time you think was put into it*
Shadowing: (1-10)
*How well is it shadowed?*
Color Blending: (1-10)
*How well the made pallet was used to blend colors*

Your own comment: " "
*please no bashing on either as we are supposed to be respectable members of this community*

P.S: Me and Fuz tried to join up once or twice but the fact that we hate each other and have totally opposite opinions doesnt help. :-)

--Neo--

Jun 18 2002, 10:31 am

~Beasted
Jun 18 2002, 10:36 am
In response to FuZzY DiCe
Wow man :-) I didnt see that comming, nice work. I see now who is the best 2der outside of DM. I'll just have to try harder next time :-)
Jun 18 2002, 10:40 am
NeoHaxor-
Originality: (1-10)
8 (Looks like an alien from a show i watched.. well not to the same but :P)
Dedication: (1-10)
8 (you didnt spend to to much time on it, But you did good and can do better)
Shadowing: (1-10)
8 (Could of used alittle more shadowing, to make him look perfect)
Color Blending: (1-10)
9 (i like the color blending mixed in him.)


Fuzzy Dice-
Originality: (1-10)
3 (Looks like Street Fighters guy..)
Dedication: (1-10)
8 (You did a pretty good job on it.)
Shadowing: (1-10)
8 1/2 (Good job on shadowing)
Color Blending: (1-10)
8 (Good job on color blending.)


No one told me how to vote, i did it from my own prospective.
So dont you go around saying Neo Told me to vote how i did.

RaeKwon
Jun 18 2002, 10:46 am
Originality: (1-10)
Neo:8 (Not like anything I've seen)
Fuzzy:5 (Looks like something from street fighter)
Dedication: (1-10)
Neo:5 (You can do better!)
Fuzzy: 8(Looked great!)
Shadowing: (1-10)
Neo:8
Fuzzy:7
Color Blending: (1-10)
Neo:6
Fuzzy :8
Your own comment: "Both looked great, but I liked Neo's more, it was original. And Fuzzy's looked EXACTLY like something from Street Fighter"
Jun 18 2002, 11:02 am
In response to Sariat

Street Fighter

Mine
Sorry for making it good next time i'll screw up
Jun 18 2002, 7:39 pm
Originality: (1-10)
neo: 5, gangsta namekian...wtf??
fuz: 5, too cliche
Dedication: (1-10)
neo: 7, looks like some good time was put into it
fuz: 9, looks almost professional
Shadowing: (1-10)
neo: 7, theres no real light source...and circles dont count as shadows
fuz: 9, thats some nice CvS style lighting
Color Blending: (1-10)
neo: 7, meh its ok
fuz: 9, god i love CvS style

overall: i like fuzzy's. neo's is good but fuzzy's is almost pro. gjgjgj
Jun 19 2002, 11:18 am
In response to FuZzY DiCe
Originality 0. It's Loures mountain garb for the monk class from Dark Ages Online. http://www.darkages.com/webpages/community/lore/ Raeven_Color/mmonk5.html

Even so, if you really draw it, the work is very good. I wonder why you didn't enter it in the DA art contest.

Why don't you each draw the same character in the same pose your opponant used to verify that it's original work? That means Fuzzy draws the Dark Ages monk from the back pointing to the right and Neo draws his green dude checking his nails.
Jun 19 2002, 12:06 pm
In response to Shadowdarke
Yes i based it off the monk..didnt think it was gonna be judges on originality, i made it like 4 days ago...or is there another art competition? and whats the point of changing the stances?
Jun 19 2002, 12:08 pm
In response to FuZzY DiCe
To prove that you really drew it... I have my doubts. Neo's work seems original to me. I believe he did draw it himself. Yours looks like a rip. I say Shadowdarke has the right idea....

~X
Jun 19 2002, 12:27 pm
In response to Xooxer
Just like you Fuzzy...

Why are you so scared of Neo? You're the one blabbing your mouth 24/7 :D
Jun 19 2002, 12:28 pm
In response to Sariat
Why are you egging him on?
Jun 19 2002, 12:33 pm
In response to JordanUl
JordanUl wrote:
Why are you egging him on?

"Egging"?
Jun 19 2002, 12:49 pm
In response to Sariat
My god... It means your asking him to start a fight.
Metaphor.
Jun 19 2002, 5:27 pm
In response to Xooxer
MEH...whatever i'll change the stances later it took away 1 of my summer days just making it...
Jun 19 2002, 5:34 pm (Edited on Jun 19 2002, 5:40 pm)
In response to Xooxer
the reason why it looks ripped is cuz he's flipping GOOD. does it ever occur to you that someone can actually be that GOOD?

jesus god i would know if it was a rip...i play both capcom and snk games like hell and that looks pretty flipping original to me.
Jun 19 2002, 5:39 pm
In response to Irrelevant
Wow, even if he did you just made yourself look like an idiot.
Jun 19 2002, 5:40 pm
In response to JordanUl
*Eggs Sariat*
Jun 19 2002, 5:42 pm
In response to Garthor
Hey!!! Don't gotta make fun of me!
Jun 19 2002, 5:47 pm
In response to JordanUl
irrelevant knows me irl. i showed him the progression of the sprite so he KNOWS i did it. you idiots need to get used to the fact that not everybody on byond sucks at spriting
Page: 1 2